I loved (to the point of learning how to do it at home, in the sous vide) the butter-poached lobster tails at Narcoossee. We bought the recipe book that had the almond crusted cheesecake from Narcoossee and the truffle mac n cheese at Yachtsman. Hubby is pretty sure the filet from the Yachtsman was the best of the three he had as well.
We're huge fans of crème brulee (we had it as our wedding dessert in lieu of cake), and the one at Yachtsman was probably the best, with Narcoossee a close second.
We did eat at Le Cellier on both of our visits, and enjoyed it the first, but not so much the second. We won't be prioritizing it on the next trip.
The wild boar tenderloin at Jiko is what put it on our list for the upcoming visit, and I am excited to give Flying Fish a try. We're also doing more of the F&W fest meals this go around.