Personally I would choose the All Star. But I am a Disney fiend and I love the themeing at the All Star resorts. But it would depend on who I was going with too, particularly if I wasn't doing Disney and also would depend on how long the stay would be. There is LOTS more drawer space at the Worldgate. The bathroom is rather bland and mine was fairly small (the door, when you opened it, did touch the toilet) and it has an odd oval tub and shower with a curtain on a curved rod...it is hard to describe. But it was fine for me. I was alone so there was tons of space.