Guys thank you so much for your responses - they are really helpful.
bicker - for me part of the appeal of BCV / BWV is the proximity to the parks, but I think for a trip with no parks I would prefer to be at VWL for sure. This trip we are doing parks though. VWL does sound lovely!
Hilary - biased? No never I am sure
You have said one of my concerns which is the separation from the main lodge and distance to Roaring Forks. Howveer I suspect this would be no different to BCV... or would it? I have made a very careful mental note to request a room not on the ground floor!!! I couldn't be coping with wildlife round my feet
Moira - DH has agreed that as we have stayed at SSR 2 trips out of 2 he will miss it this time (assuming we can get in elsewhere). It was a hard fought battle
You see part of me thinks I would prefer the WL to the VWL (for a weekend some time perhaps) so it's interesting what you say. It's also interessting that you say you enjoyed it but wouldn't go back... but I guess like you say your priorities may differ from ours at WDW (we will be having some days at the end to do some offsite stuff so being near to that while we are DVCing isn't quite so important as it might otherwise be!)
Andy - Thank you I imagine the boat is a lovely way to travel. I like your idea of some time at each definitely - but we are already doing a similar plan to yours and I think another move might just be one too many for us! I do like to experience different resorts though so normally I would go for that idea totally. (We are doing 11 nights DVC / 4 nights HRH & 5 nights offsite villa)> it looks like you and others all agree the buses are fine which pleases me no end!
JakkiI think VWL would be especially lovely at Xmas. The tree at WL in December 04 was absolutely out of this world! I haven't asked on the main DVC boards partly because I don't want to tempt fate
Kaylee Well if you still liked it even with the dumpster view that must be good
I liked the look of the pool when we saw it and I'm sure you're right that the girls would too.
Thank you all ever so much for your really helpful advice. I am confident now if we can't get BCV we will enjoy a stay at VWL (was there any doubt?).
I think this would make me reassess our dining decisions. DH & I have a very long list of possible restaurantd for August,. but if we do end up at VWL I will instead go for MK resort diniing I think in the main.... 'Ohana, Cali Grill, Narcossees, Artist Point spring immediately to mind
Thanks again
I will post back on Tuesday and let you know how we get on