Trial Run for Dogs in Resort Rooms

Do you think dogs should be allowed in guests' rooms?


  • Total voters
    1,260
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
Just to give the people who have no idea what it is like to suffer with asthma and allergies, here is a little idea of what it is like.

Strip down to your underwear and roll around in a bed of poison ivy then, rub it in your eyes, and then chew on it to your whole mouth is coated. Then take all your bedding and pillows and rub the poison ivy in it as well, and then try to sleep. This is what it is like to be someone who has allergies, and this is why it is such a big deal. Then try doing it for everyday of your entire life.

I take two medications and get 7 allergy shots every week, so that I can lead a somewhat normal life and make it to work to support my family. So yes it is a big deal.

I get allergies. We have a milk and egg allergy in our house. That means that a child dripping her ice cream next to ours can send us to the ER. So we plan our lives around it - and yes it sucks. I would love if some place became a dairy free resort. But that is never going to happen, nor do I expect it to.

I feel for the people who had vacations planned before this was announced - they had no say in the matter and it was sprung on them without warning and eliminated the possibility to plan around it.
 
You should be able to get accommodated at another resort, or get upgraded at no cost. Folks are reporting good results by expressing their concerns in writing.

WDW.Guest.Communications@disneyworld.com
And cc these folks too:
Robert.a.iger@disney.com
George.Kalogridis@disney.com
Thank you I have tired and I emailed and they called me and said that I can pay to upgrade but after seeing people having success I did email George last night expressing my displeasure and concerns for our family so we shall see thanks again!
 
I'm clearly in the minority but I am excited. We'll try it once and see how it goes. We are FL residents and get to the World pretty frequently. We like to take short weekend trips and sometimes don't go to the park. I think we will try Ft. Wilderness with our pup and see what happens.
 
Yes, of course, but your dog can't be part of this enjoyment of things at the resort. No pools, no cafes, no public walkways. Just your room and the doggie relief area.

In theory, until someone goes to the gift shop or QS with little Rover or "Fifi" in their purse. :dog::):scared: Because we know Disney Guests always follow the rules, and Disney always enforces. :rolleyes1
 


Has anyone gotten upgraded by calling? We have been booked at POR since December and although we have 2 dogs and I LOVE dogs I am no happy about this. I don't know a dog that doesn't bark when someone knocks on a door and I always hear housekeeping knocking on doors before entering. I also don't want to have to worry about my children stepping in a mess that someone forgot to clean up! If they want to include dogs why don't they just build a resort that is geared towards dogs and their owners. It could be really cute and then maybe both sides would be happier!
 
Last edited:


Nobody (at least not me) is discounting your allergies (I too am allergic to cats and have asthma) . I believe my question as well as many other posters is how does this affect your flying or when you pass a service animal in the parks? As I have posted elsewhere DH is a pilot at SW and if you are on a plane with a service animal, the service animal and its passenger get priority and you can stay on that flight or they will accommodate you on another flight. If you have a life threatening allergy they MAY ask to see a letter from your doctor.

I medicate myself before the flight and have my inhaler with me at all times.

The big problem becomes when I need to sleep, if a dog or cat has been in the room before then it would have to be steamed cleaned for me to get a good nights sleep. Disney isn't guaranteeing this with this new policy, since it would mean that they would probably end up with dog rooms not being occupied a lot of the time. Also, pets leave dander on every surface they sit on, so all the common areas that dogs are allowed would also have to be cleaned in order to accommodate guests with allergies.

Luckily my asthma and allergies are not life threatening, but I would be completely miserable sleeping in a room that a pet had previously been in. For others their asthma is life threatening, and I think they should be accommodated.

Service animals are not a common occurrence at most resorts, thus they don't leave a lot of dander and there isn't a build up on surfaces. When you add more pets to the mix, there will be.
 
Nobody (at least not me) is discounting your allergies (I too am allergic to cats and have asthma) . I believe my question as well as many other posters is how does this affect your flying or when you pass a service animal in the parks? As I have posted elsewhere DH is a pilot at SW and if you are on a plane with a service animal, the service animal and its passenger get priority and you can stay on that flight or they will accommodate you on another flight. If you have a life threatening allergy they MAY ask to see a letter from your doctor.

I used to be allergic to most animals as a child. I had the trio of asthma, allergies and hay fever. As I've gotten older I've fortunately grown out of the worst of the symptoms and tend to get some itching and running nose/eyes now at most. My son has inherited the conditions, which I hope one day he will grow out of too.

So how do we manage. To start with, avoidance is key. Where possible try not to stroke animals, or visit homes with animals. Allergies tend to be worse indoors than out, because of the concentration of allergens. Occasionally well-meaning strangers with dogs have mistaken my sons resistance to go near their dog as fear, actually bringing doggy over to meet DS, claiming that the dog won't hurt him and his name is ... (I on the other hand am terrified. Dogs and spiders...can't stand either).

Sometimes it's not possible to completely avoid though...because of service dogs and real life etc (though I've only ever come across a handful of SDs). We take nasal sprays daily. I find Beconase or Flixonase help to reduce brief exposure to allergens. So if we sat next to a dog owner at the doctors for a few minutes we are generally ok.

For longer exposure (e.g. visiting a property with animals/animal fur or sitting next to a person with an animal for extended periods of time) we have to take antihistamines an hour prior. So, if I'm flying from Washington to Orlando and I notice a doggy in a carrier is coming on our flight, we will pop a pill just incase. Now this makes us feel extremely drowsy - which is great for flying! However, this is not the way I want to fee once I've gotten to WDW! I want to be lucid and energetic enough to enjoy.

Allergies are miserable and whilst it's realistic to think Disney will deep clean every room and there will likely be no issues...what if there was? What if you end up the unlucky person with the reaction. It has the potential to somewhat spoil a very expensive vacation.

I used to find the horses on Main Street MK would sometimes spark my allergy. I remember one occasion I had forgotten my nasal spray and I had to purchase an antihistamine in MK from a gift shop. An hour on I was lying on the pavement in front of the castle, dosing off to sleep. People must have thought I was drunk. It takes a good six hours for the effect of the antihistamines to wear off.

You can buy non-drowsy antihistamines...in my experience they either still make me and DS drowsy or are less effective.

I hope that helps.

Just a note: I have no issue with Disney extending resorts to welcome dogs. I take issue with the timeframe given. They ought to have started it Jan 2019, when people hadn't yet booked and could have made more informed decisions. They should also have considered the resorts, ensuring affordable 5 person accommodation was still available (and not CBR which is a building site).
 
Good. Now people won’t be surprised.

I'm locked into a group trip with my daughter's dance company at POR in a couple of months. Neither the TA nor the studio has notified people (nor Disney, of course) - I doubt anyone will look at the booking page at this point. I emailed the TA to suggest they let people know about the policy change - there's such an age range for the kids that I have no idea who's going. I had mentioned upthread that I ran into some families that are going on the trip at a road race to raise money for training service dogs, and almost everyone had no idea.

I really think it would be helpful if people were notified soon, since our balance is due in a couple of days and some may want to figure out their options or if they still want to participate. I asked the TA about securing non pet friendly rooms. I'm told the "best we can do" is request.
 
I'm clearly in the minority but I am excited. We'll try it once and see how it goes. We are FL residents and get to the World pretty frequently. We like to take short weekend trips and sometimes don't go to the park. I think we will try Ft. Wilderness with our pup and see what happens.

We have a travel trailer and have taken one of our doggies with us to FW. They have a huge dog park that she really enjoyed and she enjoyed walking around the loops with us and getting lots of attention.

I won't speak but the vacation we take with the dogs they're pretty much with someone the whole time

Same here. We only take them when we camp, we're either at the camper with them or they go hiking/walking with us.
 
As a dog allergy sufferer, I sent an email to George K yesterday. A customer service representative called me about 30 minutes later. She was very pleasant, but admitted to be reading from a script. She did confirm that this idea came about after the dogs in hotels during IRMA went so well. I asked if guests were expected to put up with barking dogs for up to 30 minutes without complaint and she said "Yes." I asked her if that was fair if we had returned to the hotel to nap. She did not respond. I ask her what families with dogs were supposed to do if they arrived at the hotel before their room was ready, or needed the dog to remain at the hotel after the 11am check out time. She said there would be a dog room with cages set up for exactly that scenario. (???). There were also questions she could not answer (no answers on her script). Why will they need to deep clean rooms dedicated to dogs when supposedly only dog families will stay in them and clearly, they are not allergic? Why the charge for YC was $75 and the charge for the other 3 resorts was $50. How did they justify charging more for YC? How were dogs supposed to get to the dog friendly rooms without walking through public areas? She did say that I should add a note that I needed a "no dog in room previously" to every reservation in the future.

I also discussed the fact that the reason I was so concerned was that Disney CMs have a horrible reputation for ignoring guests' bad behavior and looking the other way. I gave her specific examples from my last trip. She assured me that her boss was addressing that exact issue. She also alluded to the fact that the level of concern people have over this "trial" was really surprising to them. She said both dog owners and non dog owners seemed to happy with dogs in the resorts during IRMA.
 
Ok, I thought you were referring to the population as a whole and not just on this thread.

I didn't read every word of some of the more lengthy posts, but I didn't notice anyone in favor of this commenting that they would sit in the room with their pets the majority of the time. Maybe I missed that though.



Our Newfie loves the facility we board her at. She takes off without looking back and DH feels a little betrayed lol (he typically drops her off). She gets to run around outside with other big dogs all day and get filthy and swim. They don't see other Newfies much so she gets tons of attention.

I tend to think newbies are going to make the mistake of not understanding what a Disney parks vacation entails and bring a dog thinking it will be great to have the family pet with them. Not necessarily getting the logistics of getting back and forth and time constraints, how long rides, reservations, etc. will actually take. How much time it will actually take in the parks to see and do what they want to do. The dog lovers who are all day park goers already likely won't bring their dogs.

And I agree I know many dogs who love their kennel or pet sitting arrangements.

Newfies btw are such GORGEOUS dogs! But wow, I can't imagine the care for that much fur. It's going back several years, but when I was running rescue we had a "celebrity" dog attend one of our fundraising events. He was a Newfie who won Best in Show probably 12 years ago or so in the Westminster Dog Show. His name was Josh and he was just the sweetest thing. We don't see many of them around so I'm sure you must get a lot of attention when you are out with her.
 
Some of the suggestions on this thread have really jumped the shark.

My favorites are:

* Punish Disney by having everyone ask for a deep cleaning even if it's not necessary. That'll teach 'em!
* Follow dog owners around with your phone and document every single possible transgression. Flag down every available CM and show them the photos and videos. Go to the front desk and demand that the manager view your photos and videos. That'll teach 'em!
* Lastly (and this one is my favorite), while at the front desk DEMAND that you be compensated for the time you spent doing your junior sleuthing because you are obviously doing their job for them. That'll teach 'em! Oh, and we get a free lunch in the process!
 
:tinker:Strange how all of this occurs right at almost Halloween and the upcoming holidays $$$ ... people upgrading to a more expensive hotel if they can get a room as we all know how booked they get between now and New Years.
 
Some of the suggestions on this thread have really jumped the shark.

My favorites are:

* Punish Disney by having everyone ask for a deep cleaning even if it's not necessary. That'll teach 'em!
* Follow dog owners around with your phone and document every single possible transgression. Flag down every available CM and show them the photos and videos. Go to the front desk and demand that the manager view your photos and videos. That'll teach 'em!
* Lastly (and this one is my favorite), while at the front desk DEMAND that you be compensated for the time you spent doing your junior sleuthing because you are obviously doing their job for them. That'll teach 'em! Oh, and we get a free lunch in the process!

Oh and phoning local Animal Services instead of the front desk. Do you really think Animal Services is coming out to WDW to give tickets?
 
I tend to think newbies are going to make the mistake of not understanding what a Disney parks vacation entails and bring a dog thinking it will be great to have the family pet with them. Not necessarily getting the logistics of getting back and forth and time constraints, how long rides, reservations, etc. will actually take. How much time it will actually take in the parks to see and do what they want to do. The dog lovers who are all day park goers already likely won't bring their dogs.

And I agree I know many dogs who love their kennel or pet sitting arrangements.

Newfies btw are such GORGEOUS dogs! But wow, I can't imagine the care for that much fur. It's going back several years, but when I was running rescue we had a "celebrity" dog attend one of our fundraising events. He was a Newfie who won Best in Show probably 12 years ago or so in the Westminster Dog Show. His name was Josh and he was just the sweetest thing. We don't see many of them around so I'm sure you must get a lot of attention when you are out with her.
Newbies believe they can just hop from park to park because they bought the park hopper option. When I try to explain travel time and security they don't believe me. Some people just have to learn for themselves Disneyworld is a unique vacation experience.
 
I tend to think newbies are going to make the mistake of not understanding what a Disney parks vacation entails and bring a dog thinking it will be great to have the family pet with them. Not necessarily getting the logistics of getting back and forth and time constraints, how long rides, reservations, etc. will actually take. How much time it will actually take in the parks to see and do what they want to do. The dog lovers who are all day park goers already likely won't bring their dogs.

And I agree I know many dogs who love their kennel or pet sitting arrangements.

Newfies btw are such GORGEOUS dogs! But wow, I can't imagine the care for that much fur. It's going back several years, but when I was running rescue we had a "celebrity" dog attend one of our fundraising events. He was a Newfie who won Best in Show probably 12 years ago or so in the Westminster Dog Show. His name was Josh and he was just the sweetest thing. We don't see many of them around so I'm sure you must get a lot of attention when you are out with her.

You're probably right there.

The fur is unreal! Our Roomba definitely works overtime! Knowing what the carpet in our travel trailer looks like after a weekend camping I would feel terrible for a housekeeper having to attempt to get up all that fur. We have very light colored carpet in a couple of our bedrooms and her black fur just sticks to it, it's even hard for the Roomba to get it up.

I remember seeing Josh on the dog show! Our city is very dog friendly and we've only seen 3 out and about in the years we've lived here. Kids especially love her, they think she looks like a huge bear walking around.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

GET A DISNEY VACATION QUOTE

Dreams Unlimited Travel is committed to providing you with the very best vacation planning experience possible. Our Vacation Planners are experts and will share their honest advice to help you have a magical vacation.

Let us help you with your next Disney Vacation!











facebook twitter
Top