I’ve been an AP holder for about 10 years in a row now, & several off & on years before that. Since I’m out of state, I have to buy the incredipass. FYI, my $1200 renewal price is also a small fortune, certainly not pennies. APs get NO advantage in booking LL,
genie+ or VQ boarding groups. Where did you hear that they did? The people who get a slight advantage booking some of those things are staying onsite. Many “locals” wouldn’t be staying onsite, so they won’t get that advantage. What type of ticket you buy doesn’t have any effect on getting LL or a BG. Where you stay does.
Since I’m a tourist with an AP who travels 2-4 times a year, stays deluxe, usually CL, eats at signature restaurants , I’m spending a fortune with Disney every year. Pretty sure I spend more per person per trip than a lot of other tourists coming once a year, staying at a value or offsite & eating quick service. By your theory, I should get some extra advantages I guess.