CARNIVAL VS DCL: The discussion and comparison thread!

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm sure you could if you wanted to, they aren't going to push you off the boat :) But we have done it, and it was pretty neat. We went with a private tour so there were just 4 people, myself, my son and another couple who had booked the same thing. We did that, plus snorkelling and then a stop at a beach with lunch. It was a great day, one my son's favourite excursions.

We are all fascinated … but scared of stingrays. I know people can get stung even during those excursions. Better be safe than sorry. LOL
 
We've only done stingray excursions in Cayman! And honestly, it wasn't like being swarmed with hundreds of stingrays, it was maybe dozen or less around the entire sandbar with quite a few boats in the area. But yes, you can stay in the boat and watch from afar if you want - no one will force you in the water!
View attachment 587999

That’s what it looks like???? That’s Stingray City??? It’s beautiful!!
 
Special request: After spending some time revamping the first post, I decided to highlight Carnival private islands and areas that they visit. I have visited Half Moon Cay, Grand Turk and Princess Cays so I added some pictures.

However, I haven‘t visited Amber Cove yet (soon soon!) nor Mahogany Bay (someday!) …

If you have some good pictures from Amber Cove and/or Mahogany Bay to share, please share them. I’m very limited in the number of pictures I can put on the first post so I will only pick one or two… but I think they would be a great addition to the first post! :)

I’m debating whether or not I should keep the links to reviews of the old ships that were recently scrapped or simply remove them from the first post since those ships are gone… What do you think?
 
Have you seen pics of Carnival Magic with the new paint job? She looks awesome! I saw yesterday that Carnival Pride, (I think) is headed to Europe for her new paint job.

I did! I love it.

However, I wish they would have added the same font as Mardi Gras or... Another fun font.
 
Special request: After spending some time revamping the first post, I decided to highlight Carnival private islands and areas that they visit. I have visited Half Moon Cay, Grand Turk and Princess Cays so I added some pictures.

However, I haven‘t visited Amber Cove yet (soon soon!) nor Mahogany Bay (someday!) …

If you have some good pictures from Amber Cove and/or Mahogany Bay to share, please share them. I’m very limited in the number of pictures I can put on the first post so I will only pick one or two… but I think they would be a great addition to the first post! :)

I’m debating whether or not I should keep the links to reviews of the old ships that were recently scrapped or simply remove them from the first post since those ships are gone… What do you think?

I know we've been to both, I'll try to see if I have any pictures. I think most of our photos in Mahogany Bay were of us holding sloths though! :laughing:

I think you should be fine to delete those links. The ships aren't available to sail any longer so I don't see why anyone would need an immediate review of one!
 
Hi all. Dcl convert here as well. Have cruised RC (once in 1996), DCl (2013 and 2014) on the Dream and Fantasy and then switched over to Carnival and never looked back. Disney got us to try cruising as a family. My husband was super hesitant to cruise but by the second day on the Dream he said he would not do a cruise that short again (lol…didn’t want to say l told you so, but l did!)

After our second cruise on the Fantasy in 2014 we decided to just look at other cruise lines. Our boys loved cruising but the prices on Disney were so high and l figured, after a few years, the characters wouldn’t be as important.

we booked a last minute 8 night on the carnival sunshine in 2016. Though we had a not so great room location beneath a loud club, we absolutely loved the ship and my boys enjoyed the activities and amenities on board even more than Disney cruises! My husband enjoyed the casino and l enjoyed the more adult entertainment as well while the boys enjoyed the kids clubs. My middle ds, who is not super social and didn’t really enjoy the Disney clubs had to be pried out of the carnival activities to do things as a family. We were sold! Our service was just as good or better than on the Disney ships as well.

since our first cruise we’ve done a 6 day on the magic in2017, a 7 day on the magic in 2018, a couples only 3 day on the liberty in 2019. We also had a cancelled cruise in 2020. We cancelled the 2020 cruise (were supposed to sail in February and we cancelled due to my sons wrestling schedule, not Covid) and I’ve been itching to cruise ever since!

we currently have an October 2021( couples only) cruise on the elation as well as a family spring break cruise on the Mardi Gras.

im so happy that dcl got us into cruising (especially my dh) but we will never go back to Disney. The price tag (though we can afford it) is just no longer palatable. Given the fact that my kids love carnival, even if it was pricier, we’d likely stick with them. They are so excited to try the roller coaster they can hardly stand it!

happy cruising to all!!!
 
Hi all. Dcl convert here as well. Have cruised RC (once in 1996), DCl (2013 and 2014) on the Dream and Fantasy and then switched over to Carnival and never looked back. Disney got us to try cruising as a family. My husband was super hesitant to cruise but by the second day on the Dream he said he would not do a cruise that short again (lol…didn’t want to say l told you so, but l did!)

After our second cruise on the Fantasy in 2014 we decided to just look at other cruise lines. Our boys loved cruising but the prices on Disney were so high and l figured, after a few years, the characters wouldn’t be as important.

we booked a last minute 8 night on the carnival sunshine in 2016. Though we had a not so great room location beneath a loud club, we absolutely loved the ship and my boys enjoyed the activities and amenities on board even more than Disney cruises! My husband enjoyed the casino and l enjoyed the more adult entertainment as well while the boys enjoyed the kids clubs. My middle ds, who is not super social and didn’t really enjoy the Disney clubs had to be pried out of the carnival activities to do things as a family. We were sold! Our service was just as good or better than on the Disney ships as well.

since our first cruise we’ve done a 6 day on the magic in2017, a 7 day on the magic in 2018, a couples only 3 day on the liberty in 2019. We also had a cancelled cruise in 2020. We cancelled the 2020 cruise (were supposed to sail in February and we cancelled due to my sons wrestling schedule, not Covid) and I’ve been itching to cruise ever since!

we currently have an October 2021( couples only) cruise on the elation as well as a family spring break cruise on the Mardi Gras.

im so happy that dcl got us into cruising (especially my dh) but we will never go back to Disney. The price tag (though we can afford it) is just no longer palatable. Given the fact that my kids love carnival, even if it was pricier, we’d likely stick with them. They are so excited to try the roller coaster they can hardly stand it!

happy cruising to all!!!

Welcome! :jumping1:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

GET A DISNEY VACATION QUOTE

Dreams Unlimited Travel is committed to providing you with the very best vacation planning experience possible. Our Vacation Planners are experts and will share their honest advice to help you have a magical vacation.

Let us help you with your next Disney Vacation!


GET UP TO A $1000 SHIPBOARD CREDIT AND AN EXCLUSIVE GIFT!

If you make your Disney Cruise Line reservation with Dreams Unlimited Travel you’ll receive these incredible shipboard credits to spend on your cruise!















facebook twitter
Top