We stayed in RPC at the GF Feb 1-8, and had a very nice trip. We got our room request, were met at the curb and escorted up, and didn't have any real issues or problems (other than MB issues, but this time they related more to the parks than the resort room and elevator). Overall it was a wonderful trip, both in regards to RPC and to the GF. While we didn't have any problems, there was also nothing that really wowed us or knocked our socks off, but that's really ok, it's just always a nice surprise when something amazing happens or someone just goes above and beyond.
In the lounge, the majority of CMs were pleasant but unremarkable, there were a few that were excellent, and a couple that seemed a little less than thrilled with requests but were professional enough about it, their demeanor just betrayed their actual feelings lol. It didn't stop us from asking for things like drinks, etc, we just were happy when we saw certain CMs in the lounge knowing it would be a more pleasant experience. Overall we didn't have any issues, and usually we could find a CM easily to get drinks or ask questions, a couple of times we had to wait quite a while. There were a couple of apparent managers in suits there a lot, I did have to ask them a couple of times since I saw them and not a regular CM. They were happy to help, but weren't asking us if we needed anything when we were obviously standing around waiting.
The food was good, somewhat varied (evening apps were always varied), and fairly plentiful. I did notice desserts weren't always filled up to the end, and they would run out of some desserts and not refill them. They had much more variety than most CLs, though, so it was less of an issue. At breakfast they sometimes seemed to get overwhelmed between clearing tables, replenishing food, and handling guest requests. If you have 2 people finding a table would not be a problem, with 6 we did sometimes have to check back or take it to the room during breakfast or apps, but normally found something. They had the waffle bar 6 our of our 7 mornings, and I saw the chef preparing a special dessert once. We were in the lounge quite a bit, we hit all of the services multiple times throughout our week and made meals out of them a lot. We had breakfast in the lounge every day we didn't leave before it started, had deserts most nights, and made midday, apps, and tea probably half of the days each.
We loved the room, we got our request of the 4th floor overlooking the beach pool and Poly. Close to the lounge but not on top of it, you can see the lobby when going to or from your room, you can hear the orchestra from near the door, and our kids could watch the bucket dump in the kids play area. I have found over the years that a good room and view matters a lot to us, and really elevates the stay if all else is equal, so that really helped our stay. I also like the extra wet bar and huge storage area under that sink that those rooms have. I know I've read a lot of people saying the GF rooms are dated or tired, but I haven't felt that way and like the rooms. They aren't the new style Disney is going to, but I don't have a problem with them and like that they all have a daybed, and ours was in good shape.
We've stayed in all CLs except AKL, CR tower club, and now GDT, and RPC and The Poly are my 2 favorite, I've thought about it a lot and I can't pick one over the other. I love them both, and they both have different strengths. It's a tie, and either is great.