Yes and no. We're OK with pretty much anything except the All Stars (I would be rolling my eyes so hard at the three-story football helmet that I'd be in danger of bumping my brain), but if someone offered me a free trip and said I had to stay at one of the All Stars, I'd be on it like nobody's business (similarly, I'd never stay off site if I had my druthers, but a few years ago we lucked into a free stay at an off-site time share, and we couldn't pass up a deal like that). There are resorts I don't like for aesthetic reasons like CR (unattractive exterior) or BWI (vomiting clown pool) but again, if those were the only ones available, I'd still go for it.
Resorts can surprise you. We stayed at POR back in '14 solely because of its bed setup, and we ended up liking it a lot.