alyce and I both received blue pirate thrones for the bronze key, and then stayed in the treasure room with CL_TwirlerGirl for about an hour to see who received what. I think our treasure room was tapped out; the huge majority of people opening chests (mostly bronze, but some silver and gold) received nothing at all. The bronze did give out other pirate thrones and a cash reward once, and the gold chest gave out a pirate wall at one point. I don't remember much other than the anguished cries of "nothing!" floating up from most of the people who tried. We kept telling people the room was empty, but I guess they don't believe talking walls. Oh yes, and quite a few people needed help figuring out how to use the keys, that was the other thing we often heard.
hagen of the soggy shoes and sunken ships