Totally agree with you - except our 2nd favorite!
We go every trip, and have for years, and have never had a bad experience. Everything is always yummy and the service is excellent.
Seems some people think the food comes out too quick, but actually, it's served family style and meant to come out that way. We don't have a problem with it. Most times the bread and salad comes several minutes before the other dishes anyway.
Guess it's mostly on the Dis that people comment on not liking it as reservations are very hard to come by! Looking forward to our next ressie in April. We always dine early, preferably at opening.