One Tree Hill vs Dawson's Creek, which was the better show?

[Buzz Rules]

One Tree Hill vs Dawson's Creek, which was the better show? If a new show could be made about the kids of the original characters, which show would you want to see a genuine sequel show created?

 

[C&Jx2]

OTH 100%!

I'm late to the game. I only watched Dawson's as it was airing and never had an interest in OTH, but my daughter recently went through a phase where she watched almost every teen show from the 90's-now. One Tree Hill is one of her ultimate favorites and I enjoyed it too! Dawson's Creek makes me cringe in so many ways.

 

[starry_solo]

Watched Dawson's for one season

Never saw OTH.

I would say neither

 

[pinkxray]

I only saw Dawson’s creek because my sister watched it. Other than Joey and Pacey, I couldn’t stand the other characters.

I did watch One Tree Hill. I enjoyed the first few seasons. Once these shows have characters that leave high school and are supposed to grow up, the shows usually take a show for the worst.

I wouldn’t really want to watch either as a reunion. I guess I don’t really enjoy watching the characters and how they turn out. I used to like Nathan and Haley on OTH, along with Peyton and started to dislike them all as the show went on. Unless they came back and did a reunion where everyone had a happily ever after I don’t want to see it.

 

[Disneylover99]

Gilmore Girls

 

[_19disnA]

Never watched One Tree Hill but recall a few episodes or Dawson's Creek. Another teen show that reminded me of 90210 and their various exploits while in high school. What tends to happen after a few years is they outgrow their parts and/or go off to college and the storyline of the original show is lost. Not sure a reunion of those who have now grown up/started families would make any sense.

 

[georgina]

Gilmore Girls

I watched Gilmore Girls with my oldest DD. She watched some One Tree Hill, no one in the family watched Dawson's Creek.

 

[Buzz Rules]

OTH fans, assuming the CW did OTH the next generation, what should the opening scene of the new pilot be?

 

[PollyannaMom]

Never saw either.

(But I do love Gilmore Girls!)

 

[Buzz Rules]

Never saw either.

(But I do love Gilmore Girls!)

I would definitely recommend OTH. It has that classic WB/Early 2000's series style feeling. It's a great series to binge watch during the summer. It will make you laugh, cry, and smile. I really hope the CW does continue the series in a sequel format.

 

[nherbert]

I vote for Dawsons Creek, watched every episode, loved it, but got frustrated with the round in circles every season - start with one guy, end with the other. Don’t know that I need a sequel though

 

[Buzz Rules]