Our family had a ball. We did this for my daughter's 8th birthday, my son was 10 and then we brought Grandpa along as well. It was $10 per person (and they do give an AP discount if you have an AP) and we each got our own cake to decorate/eat plus punch to drink. I am not sure if they let other people attend and not decorate a cake or not. The cakes are small, individual sized and we all 5 had a great time. It was held outside and lasted around 45 minutes. They have this guy named Pat E. Cake who runs the party, sings funny little songs and then at the end Mickey and Minnie make a brief appearance and the birthday guest gets their picture taken with them. I guess some people might think it is a bit hokey, but I think for an 8 and 5 year old it would be fun. Also, for $10 thats not bad by Disney standards. My little nieces just did this for their 5th birthday two weeks ago and they loved it as well!