Theming: As good as Disney has ever done. The gimmick of announcing "Andy's coming!" really works. All the CMs and every single guest froze in place until the all clear was given. Not a sound, not a movement, not the single clink of a fork could be heard. It was done probably 3 times while we were there (about 1 1/2 hours). Big applause afterwards.
Cheddar Biscuits: Excellent, we thought.
Watermelon and tomato salads: Nothing special, but did seem fresh.
Ribs: Good, not great. The only other place I've had ribs on property is the Hoop Dee Doo, and these are quite a bit better.
Chicken: Moist and tasty.
Brisket: Just okay.
Sausage: Nothing special here either.
Roast corn on the cob: Excellent. The cheese topping really does the trick.
Other sides: Mac 'n cheese, beans, slaw, potato barrels (tater tots) - nothing special here, with the slaw pretty decent.
Enormous quantity of food. We got through most of the meat, but lots of sides left over and we ate about 2 1/2 of the 4 biscuits.
I had a drink (Whinnyin' Whiskey Lemonade). Tasty but not much booze in it. I won't bother again.
We would definitely return here, as it is a fun place that probably no one else can do like Disney.