Your opinions please

[daber]

What do you think of this trade offer? Fair?

I would accept a trade of the following for the Stitch CM C Ticket pin;

Pin 2028 (DLR - Haunted Mansion Exit Sign (Dead End) CM)
Pin 7553 (The Art of Disney Animation 100 Years (Sorcerer Mickey)purchase when purchase art)
Pin 16267 (Disney Auctions - Marc Davis Oversize Pin (Maleficent) LE 100)
Pin 43761 (Disney Auctions - New Year Resolutions - Be More Generous
(Scrooge McDuck)LE 100)

If interested please let me know.

Regards,
Michael

 

[Parkhopper_Vince]

On the surface my first reaction is that it seems a little steep, but not too far off. However, I know what you are working to try to accomplish so I guess you have to take into consideration what you have into the pins to trade and whether the end result works for you.

 

[agnes!]

I'm a little confused. Are you saying that you would take all four pins in trade for the Stitch pin?

agnes!

 

[daber]

Agnes,
That's how I read it....all 4 of mine for their 1. The other non-board opinions I've been getting have confirmed my suspicions. This is way too much for this pin. But I've been see-sawing with this decision all day. As Vince said, this pin is not the end result, but one step in a three way trade. I'd hate to make this trade and then wind up with one good Stitch trade pin and surrender 4 good traders in the process. Maybe I (like you) am reading this wrong, and he wants one of mine for his. That seems more reasonable. Maybe two. My problem is I don't know how difficult this pin is to trade for. The person who wants it, quoted about $250 value on that on-line auction site.

 

[PinCrazed]

If you're talking about 4 pins for 1 it seems a bit much.