Can you share the list??
A quick list of things:
If you are going to eat off the ship and at the Dockyard, try Frog and Onion. It’s a English pub style restaurant. Also, BoneFish (not connected to US chain),
If out and about, try Rum Swizzle Inn or just try a rum swizzle, one of the drinks of Bermuda.
Take a tour of the island. My friend took a bus tour, we took a private tour for 5 hours. What we liked about a private tour is that we could gear it towards what we wanted to see, stop where we wanted and take as much or as little time somewhere.
Some of our favorite sights: Gibbs Hill Lighthouse, Somerset Bridge (smallest draw bridge in the world), Hamilton, Saint Georges. You can take a ferry from the Dockyard to Hamilton.
I have been to Bermuda staying twice at the Hamilton Princess, once @ Elbow Beach, once @ Sonesta Beach (no longer there) and once @ Cambridge Beaches. On our last trip during our tour, we went back and saw the Hamilton Princess and Elbow Beach, having a drink there. Three of our trips we rented the mopeds which we had fun doing. One trip was college week, so didn’t rent mopeds then and our last trip was a family trip with my dad, 80 at the time, as a trip remembering my mom as it was one of her favorite places.
Personally, we didn’t think the shopping in Hamilton was very good. They used to have a couple of really nice department type stores, they are no longer there. Since your time is limited, you won’t be missing a lot. Lots of neat shops in the Dockyard to explore. Enjoyed that and it’s right there at the ship.
St Georges is historical and interesting to walk around. Some ships used to dock there, as well as Hamilton. Ships can no longer dock at these two ports due to ships getting so big.
For a short stay, I wouldn’t go to the crystal caves, aquarium, or botanical gardens. Of the 3, I would go the the botanical gardens to see tropical things but only if you really are looking for things to do. From what I remember, back in the day, ships would leave NY on Saturdays, arrive in Bermuda Monday morning and leave Thursday afternoons.....3 nights in Bermuda. Now, it seems to be 2 nights. So, not a lot of time.
Horseshoe Bay is a nice beach, am sure there are others but we always went to the hotels beach.
The Naval Dockyard museum is also interesting.
Just some random ideas....
Enjoy!