You’d have to run all the numbers. Disney math gives me a headache!
We’re a family of four with two Disney adult children (14 & 11). The FD BB is a no brainer for us. On average each year we save at least $2,500 on the DDP.
I like having our trip all included and all paid for. We’ve discussed APs for many years and it just never added up for us. Especially now that their almost $1,000 each!
For two people, the AP room discounts along with TIW card, might workout to a better deal for you.
Well, I did it! I poured myself a big cup of coffee, took a deep breath, sharpened my pencil and set to work.
Quick Summary:
- 2 upcoming trips for my DD and I
- 8 nights this December 2018 & 9 nights next September 2019
- getting 9 day park hopper tickets for Dec trip and 8 day park hopper tickets for September trip
- Pop Century, Standard room both trips
- Free QS Dining upgraded to DDP in Dec. Plan to do the same for next September
The big question, would it make sense for me to upgrade our tickets to APs in December?
Did the calculations for us and since my DD will be a Disney 'adult' (at the ripe old age of 10 next year!) we will save approx $400 by going with FD rather than upgrading our December ticket's to APs. This was taking into consideration a 20% room discount figuring that was pretty much a given. Even with the AP savings, I really can't see us saving that $400 as we do not have plans to visit FL other than these 2 visits.
If my DD was going to still be 9 next year it would be a completely different story but since she's an 'adult' and therefore I would pay adult price for her dining plan (personal choice to always travel with the DDP regardless if I spend more or not. I just like the freedom it gives me to travel without looking at food prices so it's a choice I make) it's not worth it to me to upgrade to Annual Passes.
Hopefully this will help others out too. If you're traveling as 2 adults (or 2 adults plus more) and staying at a value resort, there's a good chance the FD will be the better option for you.
If you're staying moderate or deluxe it may be a totally different scenario for you.
Just wanted to share my calculations with hopes of helping someone else considering upgrading to an AP.