Holy schneike's - I miss a few days and get behind 10 pages of discussion!
Everything from Wisconsin vs BYU to post-race massages to POT to SAFD... you guys cover a lot of bases.
I will quickly answer SAFD (for both WDW and DLR):
Overrated Ride: Mad Tea Party... ok, so maybe that's not playing fair since it's not necessarily high on everyone's lists in the first place - but I love theme park rides and I can't make it through this one anymore... I'm just getting too old.
Overrated Show: World of Color - let me start by saying that we recently experienced the holiday version of this show last year and we were BLOWN AWAY - so I love the concept and the infrastructure of the show, and the original version was good, but not worth the time we waited to try and get to the front of our "terrace" so we wouldn't get an obstructed view. For all the work, I was just slightly disappointed. I was not disappointed, however, in the holiday version - it was aces!
I can't really answer Resort since we just haven't been to enough at WDW to gauge the differences, and when we stay at DLR, we never stay on property. As far as restaurants - I've enjoyed all the table service (and quick service) we've had at WDW for the most part. I liked the concept of Prime Time 50's, but didn't love what I ordered (I tried others in our party and liked their meals more.)