Plaza inn, Pecos, or Colombia harbour house?

[BlueSuitDonald]

Which would you choose?

 

[DoryGirl1963]

Columbia Harbor House !

 

[TinkSassy]

Columbia!!

 

[Happiest.Haunt_999]

Plaza.

 

[a1tinkfans]

Columbia ... sit upstairs and try to grab s window view. Yum food choices and enjoy the people watching ( and a little quieter atmosphere) for a QS
Enjoy wherever u choose

 

[iwasdaisy]

Always had great experiences at Columbia!

 

[gillep]

Plaza, no question.

 

[gharter]

Look at the menus, all very different, and then decide. You will get a good meal at all three.
My vote, Columbia or Pecos Bill, depending on the type of food I want at that time.
If you do Columbia, sit upstairs, away from the crowd.

 

[Planogirl]

Columbia Harbour House

 

[kastoney]

We enjoy the food at both the Plaza and Columbia Harbor House, but if I had to pick it would definitely be The Plaza. CHH can have long lines and get very loud and chaotic. For not much more money I prefer to sit and relax at the table service restaurant and have a much more relaxing experience.

 

[goofyintoronto]

We enjoy the food at both the Plaza and Columbia Harbor House, but if I had to pick it would definitely be The Plaza. CHH can have long lines and get very loud and chaotic. For not much more money I prefer to sit and relax at the table service restaurant and have a much more relaxing experience.

Exactly this. I do love both CHH and Plaza (Pecos menu makes me gag, and I love mexican food). Given the choice between CHH and Plaza, i'd go with Plaza. Its not much more expensive, and the environment is a lot nicer and quieter. Love the food too! CHH is a good choice of course....but i'd pick Plaza without a doubt.

 

[pattyw]

Columbia- mainly because we're seafood lovers! And we love sitting upstairs where it's fairly quiet- nice afternoon break!

 

[AUbaseballfan]

I recently (within last two weeks) has a less than desireable experience at Plaza. Two days earlier my meal at CHH was just meh. So it will be a long time before I go back to either. I have not been to Pecos.

 

[JerseyJanice]

I like them all.

Like PPs has said, check the menus and go to the one that has what you most want to order.

 

[cbonebt]

Isn't the plaza a table service?

 

[BlueSuitDonald]

Yes. Plaza is table service. They were not taking dinner reservations but as of yesterday it opened up dinner reservations.

 

[ForEver2016]

I recently (within last two weeks) has a less than desireable experience at Plaza.

Care to elaborate? Trying to decide whether or not to go to The Plaza and I’m having a hard time finding recent reviews.

 

[MainMom]

Ate at the plaza tonight. Was not impressed. It’s off of the must return list for awhile. We enjoyed it 2 years ago.

Had chh on Monday and it’s still good.

 

[AUbaseballfan]

Care to elaborate? Trying to decide whether or not to go to The Plaza and I’m having a hard time finding recent reviews.

This was my first time (and last for a long time) eating at the Plaza. This was my last meal of a first time solo trip and first week long stay. (I live 2 hours away from WDW.)


Food was not that good. I had the Fried green tomato BLT and it only had one FGT on it and wimpy bacon. Dessert was ok but by then my experience was not even salvageable.

However, what was worse was I was a party of 1 with an ADR. I didn’t realize this at first but figured out fairly quickly that I had been seated in the middle of a party of 14 (7 adults and 7 kids). They split them up in the “gazebo” room but the small table for two was left between them open. That was the table I got! The adults were talking back and forth from each table. Kids were running around. When I was escorted to my table I wasn’t even able to sit down due to it being blocked by a kid in a high chair. The cast member who seated me was oblivious and I had to ask the people at the table to move the kid so I could sit down. My waitress was the same as the large party so she didn’t even acknowledge the situation. I could also tell there were issues with cast members arguing out by the hostess stand. They were bring people to sit down at tables before the waitress even could get the tables cleaned off.

 

[BandtheBoys]

another vote for Columbia