I don't think I'll go back to the All Stars. The long bus rides and walks to the rooms aren't worth it to technically be on property. If that's where my budget is for the trip, I would look at Swan and Dolphin or Disney Springs area resorts. I loved them as a kid, and maybe this will change if I have kids, but for now it's a no.
For DVC, OKW is at the bottom of the list. The theming and how spread out the resort is, plus the distance to the parks are pretty unappealing. Saratoga Springs is just above it because it's closer to Disney Springs, but also near the bottom. Every other DVC resort I want to at least spend a night at.
I definitely understand not enjoying Caribbean Beach, especially with the size, but getting a room right near the Skyliner is fantastic. I went from walking out of my room to the Studios entrance in 8 minutes. The Jamaica bus stop is also the first stop in the morning, so I never had an issue getting to Magic Kingdom or Animal Kingdom.