Well we are on the QSDP, but I would like to book a couple of table service meals, as these are a bit more special. Anywhere nice and romantic you can recommend?
We are staying at POR for the duration of our visit. How far in advance do you recommend planning the holiday?
I would recommend planning as far in advance as you know you'll be able to travel. We generally plan 3-4 months in advance and do not have a problem getting what we want (would love to plan more in advance, but grad school schedules are not as fixed as we would like them!) We are going again in March and just made the decision to go last week and have gotten almost all the dining reservations we'd want.
I've never done the QSDP (have done regular
DDP and TiW, we are big TS eaters on vacation). In terms of QS places that we enjoy, you can't go wrong in EPCOT. Great choices and variety around WS. For somewhere romantic for table service I would recommend eating outside of the parks (not saying there aren't romantic places in the parks; however, it can be very crowded). A late reservation at California Grill can be quiet and romantic and you can watch the fireworks (can be hard to get a reservation at CG sometimes though). A dinner at California Grill is becoming a must do for us on every vacation. We went to Artist's Point at the Wilderness Lodge over Christmas and had a great meal, was not very crowded at all and the food was great. If you're looking for a non-signature experience, I would recommend Sanaa at AKL if you enjoy that kind of food, great view of the animals and a great atmosphere. The Coral Reef at EPCOT is a one of a kind experience, but it can get VERY busy sometimes and the food is good, but not the best on property. There are also various lounges (bars) at the various resorts that we've never really checked out, but they have a more adult feel and most have menus you can order from as well.
I don't know much about POR, having never stayed there, but I'm sure you could hang out and go for a walk around the hotel, sit by the pool, have dinner at the resort that would be quiet and romantic as well.
I know you said you weren't drinkers, so I won't mention drinking around the world; however, you guys could EAT around the world and pick up some quick service at each of the countries. I've done that once (my inlaws paid!) and it was a blast, you get to try a lot of food that you would probably never eat otherwise!
Its great going to Disney as a couple! You can't go wrong with your choices as long as you enjoy them!